Catering Services

Please allow us a minimum of 24 hours advanced notice for any catering orders. If you need your order before the 24 hour minimum, please call the store and we'll do our best to accommodate you. If you are ordering large trays of pasta, sandwiches or Brownie Trays, please allow 24 hours to prepare these items fresh for your event. It's worth the wait, trust us. Catering orders must be at least $150.00 and there is a $4.00 delivery fee. Catering orders scheduled for after 4PM must be over $200.00. ALL Delivery orders over $100.00 will have a 10% gratuity added. Deliveries over $150 to businesses will receive a $10.00 Sally O'Neal's gift card, maximum of $30.00 in gift cards per order. Total price shown on website does not include 10% gratuity charges. Please be aware that for their safety our drivers carry minimal change to cover your delivery order. Thank you for your cooperation.

Please call 813-251-0220 to place your orders using our gift cards or to discuss your event needs with one of our Catering Specialists. Pricing shown valid beginning July 15, 2024. Prices subject to change without notice.

Signature Pizzas & Breakfast Pizzas

You may order any of our Signature Pizzas or Breakfast Pizzas as part of your Catering order. All pizzas available on Regular or Thin Crust. Choose from our Classic White or Gluten Free (additional fee applies), and Vegan options. Please see the Signature Pizza section of our website for more information.

Appetizers & Sides

All of our Tray sized Appetizers require a minimum of 24 hours advance notice. Small Trays feed approximately eight (8) people, Large Trays feed approximately sixteen (16) people. Small Meatball Trays have six (6) Meatballs, Large Trays have twelve (12).

Breadsticks tray - Small Tray: $21.96 Large tray: $43.91 Our famous Pizza Breadsticks, topped with Garlic Butter and Parmesan Cheese. With our House Red Sauce, for dipping.

Fresh Baked Bread Rolls Tray - Small Tray: $10.23 Large tray: $24.86 Fresh baked to order in our ovens. A perfect addition to any of our fine Pastas, or Salads.

Meatballs Tray - Small Tray(6): $21.96 Large tray(12): $43.91 Our special House-Made Meatballs, simmered in our Slow-Cooked House-Made Pasta Sauce. A real crowd pleaser!

Pasta Trays

All pasta dishes require a minimum of 24 hours advance notice. Small Trays feed approximately eight (8) people, Large Trays feed approximately sixteen (16) people. Gluten Free Pastas available upon request. Please ask one of our Catering Specialists for more information, and to place your order.

Meat Lasagna - Small Tray: $95.12 Large tray: $190.25 A combination of Ground Beef, Italian Sausage, and herbs. Layered wih our House Cheese Blend and House-Made Pasta Sauce.

Spinach-Mushroom Lasagna - Small Tray: $95.12 Large tray: $190.25Fresh Mushrooms and Spinach cooked in Garlic Oil. Layered wih our House Cheese Blend, and our House-Made Pasta Sauce.

Chicken Parmesan - Small Tray: $114.89 Large tray: $229.37Linguine topped with Breaded Chicken Breast, our House Cheese Blend, and our House-Made Pasta Sauce.

Spaghetti and Red Sauce - Small Tray: $58.53 Large tray: $117.09Pasta simmered in our House-Made Pasta Sauce.

Spaghetti and Meatballs - Small Tray: $79.02 Large tray: $157.92 Pasta simmered in our House-Made Pasta Sauce, with Meatballs.

Cheese Manicotti - Small Tray: $79.02 Large tray: $158.06

Vegetable Manicotti - Small Tray: $81.60 Large tray: $163.19

Chicken and Spinach Manicotti - Small Tray: $95.12 Large tray: $189.95

Penne and Meat Sauce - Small Tray: $79.02 Large tray: $157.92 Penne Pasta topped with our House-Made Meat Sauce.

Eggplant Pasta - Small Tray: $95.12 Large tray: $190.25 Linguini topped with Breaded Eggplant, Ricotta, Parmesan Cheese, Special Cheese Blend and House-Made Pasta Sauce.

Side of our House-Made Pasta Sauce - Small: $8.78 Large: $17.57Side orders of our House-Made Pasta Sauce. Who doesn't love a little extra sauce?

Sandwich Trays

All sandwich trays require a minimum of 48 hours advance notice. Small Trays have four (4) sandwiches, Large Trays have eight (8) sandwiches. Small Tray: $42.21 Large tray: $84.43

Philly Cheesesteak SandwichShaved Ribeye Steak topped with Sautéed Green Peppers, White Onions, and melted White American Cheese on a toasted roll.

Meatball Sub House Made Meatballs simmered in our House Marinara Sauce, Topped wih our House Cheese Blend, Parmesan Cheese, on a toasted roll.

Pressed Hot Itallian SubPepperoni, Genoa Salami, and Capicolla topped with our House Cheese Blend, Banana Peppers, Red Onions. Topped with our House Dressing and served on a Toasted Roll.

Breaded Eggplant Parmesan SandwichBreaded Eggplant, Topped wih House Marinara Sauce, House Cheese Blend, and Parmesan Cheese on a toasted roll.

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich Breaded Chicken Breast, Topped wih House Marinara Sauce, House Cheese Blend, and Parmesan Cheese on a toasted roll.

Salad Trays

All salad trays require a minimum of 24 hours advance notice. Small Trays feed approximately eight (8) people, Large Trays feed approximately sixteen (16) people.

House Salad Tray - Small Tray: $51.29 Large tray: $102.59 Iceberg and Romaine Mix, Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Pepper, Black Olives, Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese, Served with House-Made Vinaigrette.

Caesar Salad Tray - Small Tray: $51.29 Large tray: $102.59Romain Lettuce, Red Onions, Kalamata Black Olives, Parmesan Cheese, Served with Coutons, and Caesar Dressing.

Chicken Caesar Salad Tray - Small Tray: $62.98 Large tray: $125.87Marinated Chicken Breast, Romain Lettuce, Red Onions, Kalamata Black Olives, Parmesan Cheese, Served with Coutons, and Caesar Dressing.

Greek Salad Tray - Small Tray: $51.29 Large tray: $102.59 Romaine and Iceberg Lettuce Mix, Tomato, Cucumbers, Red Onion, Greek Peppers, Kalamata Olives, Topped with Red Potato Salad, Feta Cheese, Served with Greek Dressing.

Mini Calzones & Breakfast Mini Calzones

All Mini Calzones require a minimum of 24 hours advance notice.

Mini Calzones - Half Dozen: $36.59 One Dozen: $75.95 Filled with our special Riccotta and House Cheese Blend, with your choice of up to three toppings:

• Meatball
• Sausage
• Pepperoni
• Smoked Ham

• Chicken
• Bacon
• Onions
• Spinach

• Tomatoes
• Mushrooms
• Green Peppers

• Banana Peppers
• Artichoke Hearts

Breakfast Mini Calzones - Half Dozen: $36.59 One Dozen: $75.95Filled with our special Riccotta and House Cheese Blend, with your choice of up to three toppings:

• Egg
• Sausage
• Smoked Ham
• Chicken

• Bacon
• Green Peppers
• Spinach
• Mushrooms

• Tomatoes

Desserts

All Brownie Trays require a minimum of 24 hours advance notice. Small Trays feed approximately eight (8) people, Large Trays feed approximately sixteen (16) people. Chocolate Decadence Cake has 12 Slices, ALL other cakes and pies have 10 Slices.

Our Famous House-Made Brownies - Small Tray: $22.51 Large tray: $45.01 Yes, an entire pan of our House-Made Chocolate Brownies! What could be better? Maybe... two trays...?

Chocolate Decadence Cake - Slice: $8.40 Whole Dessert: $92.87 Chocolate cake with chocolate icing, and chocolate ganache, topped with more chocolaten shavings. Did I mention there's some chocolate?

Key Lime Pie - Slice: $6.60 Whole Dessert: $57.69 A real Florida Tradition! Sweet, tart and tangy, this is sure to please!

Seasonal Dessert - Slice: $6.60 Whole Dessert: $70.34 Selection varys by season. Ask our Catering Specialists what is in season when placing your order.

Cinnamon Sticks - Small Tray: $21.80 Large tray: $43.61 Just like our Breadsticks, but topped with butter, and cinnamon sugar. Served with our house-made cream cheese icing for dipping.

Drinks - Soft Drinks, Teas, & Waters

We carry a variety of Soft Drinks, Teas, and Waters to meet any taste.

Diet Coke - Can: $2.12 2 liter Bottle: $5.41

Coke Zero - 12oz. Can: $2.12

Barq's Root Beer - 12oz. Can: $2.12

Fanta Orange - 12oz. Can: $2.12

Coke - Can: $2.12 2 liter Bottle: $5.41

Sprite - Can: $2.12 2 liter Bottle: $5.41

Fanta Pineapple - 12oz. Can: $2.12

Smart Water - 20oz Bottle: $5.36

Sweet Tea - Gallon: $10.23

Unsweetened Iced Tea - Gallon: $10.23

Perrier Mineral Water - 6.75oz Bottle: $3.74

Beer & Wine

We have a wide variety of Domestic, Local Craft, Import Beers and Wines available for your event. Ask one of our Catering Specialists for our current Beer and Wine lists. You must be 21 or older to purchase Beer or Wine. Proof of age is required upon delivery or pick-up.